Everybody Hates Gregg Zaun

By Scoring Positions guest contributor, Shawn. 
I greatly dislike Rogers Sportsnet analyst and former Toronto Blue Jay Gregg Zaun. I always have and I can’t foresee a future where that hate dissipates.

By lam_chihang (2011_08_13_IMG_1509 Uploaded by oaktree_b) CC-BY-2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

I don’t like to go around saying I hate people. I actually “hate” few people. But I hate Gregg Zaun.
Of course, this is in reference to Blue Jays catcher J.P. Arencibia’s rant and shots fired at analysts Dirk Hayhurst and Zaun.
My hate affair with Zaun began when he was a player.
I sat through many games with Zaun behind the plate. He was an automatic out and a complete and utter liability as a defensive catcher. If I was inching off of first base, I knew Zaun stood no chance of throwing me out, and I’m no Rajai Davis.
So when Sportsnet started bringing Zaun in to comment on playoff games, I was surprised to see his ugly, toothless mug.
I wondered what a terrible player with zero physical ability would have to lend to baseball analysis. The answer, of course, was (and is) nothing.
So when Sportsnet refocused to take the Blue Jays seriously, carrying all of the team’s games and Zaun was brought in as a full-time analyst alongside Jamie Campbell, I was disappointed.
I felt a career .250 hitter with 88 home runs and fewer than 450 RBI over a 16-season career who threw out fewer than one quarter of runners who tried to steal on him had nothing to add to the world of baseball analysis.
The idea behind analysis, of course, is someone who knows how to do something analyzing the performance of others who don’t, explaining the adjustments that need to be made in order to do that something.
Instead, Sportsnet brought in a failure to analyze the failure of other (to be fair, the Blue Jays haven’t really set the baseball world on fire the last few years) failures.
Since that time, Zaun has taken on a persona that some seem to really like and has made others want to cram a wooden kitchen spoon down his toothless facehole until it comes out the back of his braincase.
Zaun has tried to become the brassy, no-nonsense, tells-it-like-it-is, controversial baseball version of hockey’s Don Cherry, even down to the horrible, gaudy couch-and-curtain-like blazers that he wears during telecasts.
Yes, Zaun has a World Series ring. That can’t be denied, but there are a lot of players out there who backed ass backwards into a championship too, so his ring can go the way of the aforementioned wooden spoon as I see it. (He played in three games during the 1997 Florida Marlins’ World Series-winning playoff run with two at-bats and no hits. Derek Jeter, he ain’t.)
Anyway, what I’m getting at (in a really roundabout way) is that I have never put any stock in anything Gregg Zaun has ever said.
His Zaun 101 segments inspire a particular brand of hilarity. Zaun shows all the young baseball players out there how to hit or field their position, neither of which he effectively did in one of his 16 years in Major League Baseball.
It should also be pointed out that Zaun was implicated in 2007’s Mitchell Report on the use of performance-enhancing drugs in baseball, so there’s that credibility that comes from someone whose name was in that report as well.
So onto what happened today. Arencibia took to the airwaves to slam Hayhurst (who was no Pedro Martinez himself, pitching for two seasons with an ERA of nearly six) telling the world that no one on the Blue Jays respects the men, or their opinions and criticisms.
This is being seen as shots fired by Arencibia, but really, should it be a surprise to anyone? The current roster is full of players who have achieved major milestones in their careers. On the Blue Jays there is a two-time Major League home run leader, a batting champion, a Cy Young Award winner, a pitcher with two no-hitters, among others. Arencibia has already had the best offensive season by a catcher in Blue Jays history and is on pace to break that mark (according to home runs and RBI). So why, under any circumstances, is this group going to listen to anything this pair of complete and utter failures has to say about the game of baseball, an avenue of life in which they failed so miserably? Easy. They’re not going to. Ever.
Granted, Arencibia is not having the greatest season ever played, but he has 15 home runs and 38 RBI with over a week until the All-Star break, the unofficial halfway point of the season.
His on-base percentage isn’t great, he doesn’t take a lot of walks and he strikes out a ton, but this hardly warrants the kind of criticism Zaun and Hayhurst have piled on him.
Arencibia is right when he says “[Hayhurst and Zaun] quickly forget how hard this game is.”
I wonder what a pair of idiot talking heads such as Hayhurst and Zaun would have to say if they were watching players like themselves amble around aimlessly on the field of play as they did.
I remember when John Farrell left the Blue Jays to manage the Boston Red Sox and there was chatter on the internet after the Blue Jays’ blockbuster off-season of having Zaun coach the team and I lost my faith in humanity.
Unfortunately how brash he is has distracted the general Blue Jays baseball-watching public from the fact that he knows nothing about the game, as evidenced in his less-than-stellar playing career.
Thank God for Jack Morris, now when Sportsnet tells you to e-mail them for their ‘Ask The Experts’ segment, your e-mail might actually get to an expert, as they finally have one on staff.
This kind of behaviour isn’t tolerated anywhere else in the world except for sports analysis. Imagine if you and your neighbour are building a fence and his side is a complete mess that’s falling apart and full of examples of poor workmanship. Then he wanders over to your side and starts giving you advice, are you gonna take it? No chance.
The fact that Rogers pays Zaun to venture out beyond his side of the criticism fence is appalling. He’s just like any other loudmouth who tries to disguise his lack of knowledge with the volume of his voice.
About these ads


  1. You don’t have to be an all-star to know how to critique the game. Buck Martinez and Pat Tabler were awful Jays, yet they still make insightful analysis of the game. Most managers started off as mediocre players, while some all-star managers maintain losing records. By your logic, I should stop reading this post because you have never been a .300+ hitter in the major leagues.

    Whether or not you agree with Zaun’s critiques, or his Zaun 101, he does come from a place of experience. Yeah, he can come off as a bit of an asshole, and he admittedly says a lot of stupid things, but he’s not wrong in his critiques of our starting catcher. J.P. was blowing off steam because critics have been very hard on him – not surprising because he has the worst numbers of any starting catcher in the major leagues.

    1. Shawn · · Reply

      We’re not critiquing anyone’s play here, just analysis. You can trust ol’ Zauner if you want, but for me I wouldn’t trust him as far as I could throw him. Even his analysis is off-base the majority of the time, but to each his own.

    2. Pat Tabler was a shit player!? He hit .282 lifetime and was super clutch his whole career and he was league average in the field. Maybe Buck Martinez couldn’t hit .250 in a game of teeball, but he was as solid as they come defensively behind the plate. Check your facts, dumbass. Maybe Hayhurst and Zaun were shit players, but Tabby and Buck were both well-respected.

  2. I’m with you. Always liked Tabler. Martinez was solid as well. Respect their commentary a lot too. They provide some thoughtful, insightful stuff during games, unlike Zaun who digs himself into a deeper hole of incredibility every day.

  3. jayzer92 · · Reply

    Finally someone who dislikes Zaun as much as I do :) this made my day. GO JAYS!

  4. Making days is what I’m all about. Wish I could high five you through the internet, but I can’t…

  5. Those who do can. Those who cannot, comment on those who can. How many rings do you have pencil pusher?

  6. Whomever wrote this and/or agrees with this knows nothing about baseball.

    Zaun had a mediocre BA, but had a LIFETIME .344 OBP. He had a good eye at the plate, and would often see more pitches per at bat than most MLB players.

    The guy was 5’7″ and had very little help in respect to the “gene pool”. He had 1 season where he ADMITTED (like a man) steroid use, but was a 16 yr MLB vet because he was smart, worked hard, and was a very fierce competitor. He was also known for being a great teammate and he handled the pitchers very well. Those stats are not measured, but vital.

    JP is a cocky idiot will all the talent in the world, but is too dumb to use it. Sucks at handling pitchers, and struck out more in the past 3 years than Zaun did in his 16 yr career. JP is a bum and the critique is warranted.

    The writer of this knows nothing about baseball. Dumb, trashcan, moron, lowlife :)

  7. Oh BTW “amble around the field aimlessly”? Are you dumb? First of all, Hayhurst was a pitcher. Secondly, Zaun was a decent catcher who was smart, and ran the bases well…. You are really a very dumb, trash bag, maggot writer, who needs to stop “ambling around your keyboard aimlessly”.
    Have a happy Easter dumb-dumb

  8. Jeffrieb · · Reply

    You are a complete idiot. “When I was inches off first…” Wait a second, you never played mlb so you have no idea. Greg played 16 seasons of Major League Baseball. Of all of the millions of people who play baseball, this guy was not only good enough to make it into the league, but also to play for 16 years. It’s a pretty impressive feat that very few people can say they’ve done and not for the lack of trying.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: